Hello dear
Welcome To Pizza Boy Pizza
Pizza Boy Pizza, located at 618 S Marion Ave in Lake City, FL, offers a delightful Italian takeout experience that has garnered a loyal following. Known for its made-from-scratch dishes, customers rave about the flavorful pizzas, hearty baked ziti, and impressive wraps. The garlic and cinnamon knots are crowd favorites, highlighting the restaurant's commitment to quality. Despite the outdated atmosphere, the warm service and great value make up for it. Diners appreciate the generous portions and the unique offerings, such as Stromboli, making Pizza Boy Pizza a must-visit for Italian food lovers in the area.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
All Meat Stromboli
Cheese Bread
Cinna Knots (3)
Pizza Roll Special
About
Pizza Boy Pizza
Welcome to the delightful world of Pizza Boy Pizza, a hidden gem nestled at 618 S Marion Ave, Lake City, FL. Often described as the best Italian takeout in the area, this local haunt draws food enthusiasts from as far as Gainesville with its promise of freshly made dishes that boast authentic flavors.
The charm of Pizza Boy Pizza lies not only in its mouthwatering menu but also in its commitment to quality. As customer Kasie Allen aptly noted, “Everything is made from scratch,” a testament to the care evident in every dish. The pizza is a star attraction, captivating taste buds and igniting a love for Italian cuisine within those who walk through its doors. While the thick, cheesy slices often steal the show, alternatives like the Baked Ziti and the famed Ranch Chicken Wrap also shine brightly on the menu. One satisfied customer raves about the wrap, ranking it a solid 9.5 out of 10, underscoring the restaurant's dedication to crafting each plate with finesse.
Yet, it’s not just the pizza that garners rave reviews. The Garlic Knots and Cinnamon Knots also deserve special mention, with some patrons leaving with a baker's dozen to savor at home. A sweet twist waits with their rich icing, which elevates the cinnamon knots to a score of 9.7 when enjoyed together.
Of course, not every experience is flawless. Some reviews hint at menu items varying in taste, which can happen with such personalized offerings. Customer feedback suggests refining the seasoning of classic dishes like Spaghetti & Meatballs to reach the expected heights of authenticity. Although the ambiance may not be the most welcoming—described as outdated with limited seating—the food more than compensates for the surroundings.
At Pizza Boy Pizza, the staff is noted for their warm hospitality and attentiveness, making it a favorite stop for lunch or dinner alike. With a diverse menu that caters to those seeking hearty meals, the eatery strikes a balance between quality and affordability, making it a great choice for families and those on the go. The experience is best summed up by Mark Eshbaugh, who notes it as a solid middle ground for cost and quality in pizza.
If you're in Lake City, make Pizza Boy Pizza your destination. With a commitment to homemade flavors, generous portions, and friendly service, it’s the kind of place that keeps enthusiasts returning for more. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or eager to explore the richness of their sandwiches and pasta dishes, expect to be pleasantly surprised by what this inviting establishment has to offer.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place is THE BEST Italian takeout - hands down. I come all the way from Gainesville to enjoy this place with my family. It's so good! Everything is made from scratch-- &if it isn't, you cannot tell! The pizza is what started our love for this place. Tonight we explored more of their menu. My husband got Baked Ziti w/meatballs & it was such a huge portion, that he'll have lunch for tomorrow. We give the bake Ziti an 8.8 , absolutely amazing! I wanted the Philly sandwich? However, they were out of rolls because they are made fresh daily & it's 6:30pm on a Tuesday. So, instead I got the Ranch Chicken Wrap, which was the best wrap ever, I added bacon, however they forgot to add it. I still give the wrap a 9.5 out of 10. The wrap was definitely made from scratch. So delicious! My daughter had the Chef Salad, she would give the salad a 7 out of 10. Which is understandable as it was iceberg lettuce instead of romaine. Sprucing the quality would definitely give the salad a better score. My son had the Spaghetti & meatballs, he said he would rate it a 5.7 out of 10. Said more seasoning & to add parmesan cheese. I personally thought the sauce should have been thicker. The Garlic knots were great! I would rate them 8.6. The cinnamon knots were freaking amazing, with the icing being an additional 1 charge I feel it's not something you should be charged for ..it should come with it. I would give the Cinnamon knots without the icing a 7.5, & with it would be a 9.7 . We loved them so much we bought a baker's dozen to take home with 5 additional icing . .icing is made from scratch as well. We also, bought a 16in pizza which was good, but something tasted like something was missing..?? Not sure if they missed a step or changed the recipe . The dough was harder & way more denser...why change something that was perfect ? Overall rating of this place would be a 9 out of 10. Customer service was amazing & very friendly! Atmosphere here totally sucks! Its very oudated & not a friendlyatmosphere hardly any seating whatsoever. The patio furniture inside this place should be a joke. There werent enough bar stools at the bar counter...they definitely need to expand. I could see this Italian takeout place becoming an amazing restaurant. It only takes a little imagination & passion. Honestly though, this place would be the best Italian restaurant in lake city if they would just relocate & add dining! ”
“ Wow, though I've been to spots in Lake City for work or recreation for years, I don't think I've ever eaten at Pizza Boy. Many people have told me that the food was good . I finally stopped by and got a Stromboli! It was yummy! I like that they give you enough sauce for every bit of Stromboli . The only thing was that I wish the sauce was hot (temperature). Can't wait to go back and try something else! ”
“ Took advantage of a facebook special and I'd say for their prices for the pies are fair. The people running it are nice and I liked the little atmosphere inside, especially the beta fish. I've had better and worse pizzas for more money so I say this place has a good middle ground for cost and quality. They also have a variety of menu items but I got a pepperoni pizza ”
“ I love this place! When I am working in Lake City, I make a point to get lunch from Pizza Boy. I usually get the pizza roll lunch special but I have also gotten the pizzas and everything so far has been amazing! ”
“ Weird location and the random items for sale in the lobby aren’t particularly inspiring, but the food (I’ve had pizza and calzone) is good and a good value. Solid “A” grade. Will definitely be back when I pass by that way. ”
“ Little Mom & Pop pizza place. Great variety of food. Reasonable prices. Friendly staff & Great tasting food! ”
“ 1st time trying them and they didn’t disappoint at all! Had the meat lovers pizza!! Meats were high quality and pizza was fantastic! Garlic knots were ordered with extra garlic and SO GOOD! Absolutely recommend if you looking for. A small local pizza joint! ”
“ Growing up on Long Island I know what "real" New York pizza tastes like. The second you open the door the delishousnous hits you right in your stomach. I have medical appointments at the V.A. Hospital across the street and live in Valdosta, GA (65 miles) so I never miss picking up 2 large pies before returning home. ”